Giants and Monsters
Giants
Scale does something a caption never could. Make one body enormous and everyone smaller than it changes how they stand — closer together, easier with each other, unbothered by what looms over them.
There’s an old kind of scene buried under this one: a huge man planted with his legs apart, an army passing underneath, looking up without quite meaning to, finding “opportunities for laughter and admiration” in what they see. Nobody in these four collages says that out loud. Nobody has to. The looking is doing the same work it always did — half comedy, half something more private — while the small figures below just keep talking, keep posing for a photo, keep being ordinary in the shadow of something extraordinary.
That indifference is the whole point. The giant isn’t a threat to the people underneath him. He’s just the landscape — a mountain, a fact of the terrain, something you build your afternoon around without a second thought. Being gay was never the problem for gay people. It was only ever the backdrop of an ordinary life.
After Swift
Jonathan Swift wrote this scene three hundred years ago and didn’t fully know what he’d written. In Gulliver’s Travels, the giant Englishman stands “like a Colossus,” legs spread as far apart as he can manage, while the entire Lilliputian army marches underneath him — and because his breeches are torn, the soldiers get a clear look straight up. Gulliver reports, with a straight face, that this affords the men “some Opportunities for Laughter and Admiration.”
Scholars have been unpacking that line for decades. A body turned into spectacle. Thousands of small men gathered to look up at one enormous one, laughter and admiration arriving in the same breath, the giant both exposed and completely in command of the room. It’s voyeuristic. It’s frankly phallic. Swift almost certainly meant it as a joke about vanity and empire — and it works as that — but the image itself doesn’t stay contained to the joke.
These four collages take that image and turn its attention around. Swift’s soldiers can’t stop looking up. The figures here barely look at all. Whatever anxiety the giant might stir up belongs entirely to whoever’s doing the staring — not to the people standing calmly underneath him.
That’s the real subject. While straight culture keeps circling the question of what to do about gay people — how to name it, manage it, legislate it, look away from it and then look back — gay people are simply over here living, openly, honestly, unremarkably. That openness is what actually unsettles the culture that built the closet in the first place. It was never built to punish gay people for existing. It was built to make sure no one had to watch them exist in the open. The old preferred outcome was always the same: the closeted politician, married to no one, quietly finding himself through men who could be paid and dismissed, appetite intact and reputation untouched. Silence was the deal. What these collages show instead is the deal broken — the mountain simply standing there, indifferent, permanent, unbothered by who’s uncomfortable looking at it.
Call it a giant if the size is what unsettles you. The real monster is the one who decides another person’s way of living is unacceptable — unacceptable enough to erase entirely. That decision forever earns the name monster.
— Behan