These five collages take reclining odalisques by Titian, Manet, Ingres, Francesco Hayez and Theodor Aman and reconstitute them with male figures. The aim is to widen the understanding of sexual intimacy and sexual desire. Who qualifies as a voluptuary? We all do.
The odalisque is a female genre. For four centuries, European painting places a woman on a couch, turns her body toward the viewer, and calls the result art. The male version exists, but it survives only under other names: myth, sleep, athletics, the classical study.
An openly gay odalisque appears only after 1970, and it arrives the same way each time. An artist takes a famous painting and changes who is on the bed. These collages continue that practice.
The Canon
Odalisque comes from the Turkish odalık, a chambermaid in an Ottoman household. European painters turn the word into the fantasy of the harem concubine.
The lineage is short and well known: Giorgione's Sleeping Venus (c. 1510), Titian's Venus of Urbino (1538), Ingres's Grande Odalisque (1814) and Odalisque with a Slave (1839–42), Manet's Olympia (1863), and Matisse's odalisques of the 1920s.
The genre spreads across Europe in the 19th century. Francesco Hayez paints reclining odalisques in Milan, and Theodor Aman paints them in Bucharest.
The conventions stay fixed. A horizontal body, a hand at the groin, a servant in the background, drapery, flowers, exotic props. The viewer is assumed to be a man, and the body on the bed is assumed to be a woman.
Myth as Permission
Antiquity has no difficulty with the reclining male nude. The Barberini Faun (c. 220 BCE) lies asleep with his legs open. The Sleeping Hermaphroditus reads as a female odalisque from behind and reveals male genitals from the front. In 1620 Bernini carves a marble mattress for the Borghese version, now in the Louvre.
Later painters use myth as permission. The key work is Anne-Louis Girodet's Sleep of Endymion (1791). In the story, the moon goddess Selene falls in love with the sleeping shepherd Endymion.
Girodet paints Selene only as moonlight. What remains is a passive young man laid out for the viewer, while the boy Zephyr parts the branches to watch.
Abigail Solomon-Godeau, in Male Trouble, documents how French painting from the 1790s to the 1830s makes this languid male youth a central object of desire. Jean Broc's Death of Hyacinth (1801) and Hippolyte Flandrin's Young Male Nude Seated beside the Sea (1836) follow.
The Orient and the Camera
The harem fantasy has a male counterpart. Flaubert, Gide and Wilde travel to North Africa in part for the sex with men that Europe forbids. The Ottoman world has its own tradition of köçek, young male dancers painted in court miniatures.
Photography gives the genre a new cover. Wilhelm von Gloeden, working in Taormina from the 1880s to the 1930s, poses Sicilian youths on furs and draperies with the props of the odalisque. He sells the results as classical studies.
In the United States, physique photography carries the pose through the censorship years. Bob Mizer's Athletic Model Guild, founded in 1945, publishes reclining men under the label of fitness, with the posing strap as legal protection. George Platt Lynes makes more explicit reclining nudes that circulate privately.
The Reversal
After 1970 the substitution becomes the point.
Sylvia Sleigh paints Philip Golub Reclining (1971), a nude man in the pose of Velázquez's Rokeby Venus. In The Turkish Bath (1973) she replaces Ingres's women with nude male art critics, among them her husband, Lawrence Alloway.
Burt Reynolds's centerfold in Cosmopolitan (April 1972) and the launch of Playgirl (1973) bring the reclining nude man into mass media. Both are aimed at women. Both find a large gay audience.
Pierre et Gilles, working in Paris from the late 1970s, make saturated, flower-filled photo-paintings of men posed as saints, sailors and mythological figures. Kehinde Wiley's Down series (2008) places young Black men in the reclining poses of European painting.
Five Collages
Each collage begins with an odalisque ground and changes who lies on it.
The first restages Theodor Aman's Reclining Odalisque, keeping its carpets, cushions and long-necked lute.
The second restages Francesco Hayez's Reclining Odalisque, with its green curtains and view of the sea.
The third lays a male body directly over Ingres's Grande Odalisque. Her blue curtains and orange drapery remain visible around him.
The fourth uses the interior of Titian's Venus of Urbino, with the servant still at the chest in the background.
The fifth restages Manet's Olympia. A standing man takes the maid's position, and the reclining man wears Olympia's flower in his hair.
Three elements repeat. The blue moon refers to Endymion: the moon looking at a sleeping man. The Jupiter 2, the saucer from Lost in Space, places each scene inside a 1960s idea of the future. The roses replace both Olympia's hand and the bouquet her maid carries.
The largest change is in the fourth and fifth collages. In the paintings, the second figure is a servant. Here the second figure is a partner, and the subject becomes a couple rather than one body on display.
The male odalisque has existed for more than two thousand years as subtext. These collages make it context.
— Behan
Sources
Abigail Solomon-Godeau, Male Trouble: A Crisis in Representation (Thames & Hudson, 1997)
Linda Nochlin, "The Imaginary Orient," Art in America (May 1983)
James Smalls, Homosexuality in Art (Parkstone, 2003)
Allen Ellenzweig, The Homoerotic Photograph (Columbia University Press, 1992)
Thomas Waugh, Hard to Imagine: Gay Male Eroticism in Photography and Film from Their Beginnings to Stonewall (Columbia University Press, 1996)